Hi Sarah,

You have all three finishes in this one photo. Though I'm not sure if this is meant to be three finishes or two.

Let's name them:

1. Right, stipple

2. Top left, sludge

3. Bottom left, sponge smooth

I think my first choice would be 3. Bottom left, sponge smooth.

I had a little bit of concern about the color. It seems a bit dark to me. You? (I don't think you can tell color from the photograph.